1

00:00:00,858  -->  00:00:02,379
Let’s consider the weaknesses

2

00:00:02,477  -->  00:00:06,392
and things that Whonix simply
isn’t designed to do.

3

00:00:06,594  -->  00:00:10,893
So first thing, it’s obvious to an observer
that you are using TOR

4

00:00:11,223  -->  00:00:12,926
when you are using Whonix.

5

00:00:12,986  -->  00:00:16,835
It may also be obvious to an observer
that you’re using Whonix itself

6

00:00:16,999  -->  00:00:20,453
based on fingerprint information
that it may give away.

7

00:00:20,639  -->  00:00:23,914
Whonix won’t encrypt your
document by default,

8

00:00:23,987  -->  00:00:26,733
it’s just simply not supposed
to do that.

9

00:00:26,978  -->  00:00:30,579
It doesn’t clear the metadata
out of your documents.

10

00:00:30,766  -->  00:00:35,396
It doesn’t encrypt the subject
or the headers of your emails,

11

00:00:35,536  -->  00:00:39,163
encrypted emails, because that’s
not what it’s designed to do.

12

00:00:39,413  -->  00:00:43,714
Whonix doesn’t separate your
different contextual identities.

13

00:00:44,034  -->  00:00:46,393
It is not advisable,
as I previously said,

14

00:00:46,503  -->  00:00:50,636
to use the same Whonix workstation
to perform two tasks

15

00:00:50,760  -->  00:00:53,356
or endorse two contextual identities

16

00:00:53,691  -->  00:00:56,795
that you really want to keep
separate from each other.

17

00:00:56,941  -->  00:01:01,623
It probably won’t protect you against
firmware rootkits or bios attacks.

18

00:01:01,857  -->  00:01:04,775
It won’t protect you from
hardware compromises

19

00:01:04,963  -->  00:01:09,895
like the SURLYSPAWN hardware
key logo in the NSA ANT Catalog

20

00:01:10,330  -->  00:01:15,126
and the RAGEMASTER,
the VGA cable retro reflector.

21

00:01:15,324  -->  00:01:18,462
It won’t protect you against
hardware compromises like that.

22

00:01:18,601  -->  00:01:21,263
As is the same with any operating
system and application,

23

00:01:21,430  -->  00:01:23,777
there could be security
vulnerabilities

24

00:01:23,909  -->  00:01:26,337
and even a backdoor
through either deliberate,

25

00:01:26,397  -->  00:01:29,154
coerced or accidental methods.

26

00:01:29,155  -->  00:01:31,093
But this is unlikely
because Whonix

27

00:01:31,395  -->  00:01:33,863
essentially is really just
a bunch of scripts,

28

00:01:34,146  -->  00:01:37,276
and as far as I’m aware,
there’s no actual compiled code.

29

00:01:37,440  -->  00:01:39,305
Whonix is more
difficult to set up

30

00:01:39,425  -->  00:01:43,019
compared to say for example
the TOR browser on its own,

31

00:01:43,040  -->  00:01:46,785
or Tails if you’re just
using it as a live CD.

32

00:01:47,161  -->  00:01:49,236
It requires that you have
virtual machines,

33

00:01:49,336  -->  00:01:54,211
so therefore you need a hypervisor or
you have spare hardware to run it on.

34

00:01:54,426  -->  00:01:58,002
It also requires higher
maintenance than live CDs,

35

00:01:58,153  -->  00:02:00,359
as live CDs are just static.

36

00:02:00,617  -->  00:02:04,016
One of the most significant
potential weaknesses in Whonix,

37

00:02:04,422  -->  00:02:08,921
if you need that feature, is that
it is not an Amnesic system.

38

00:02:09,109  -->  00:02:11,337
So let me read from the website.

39

00:02:11,517  -->  00:02:15,927
"Unlike Tails, Whonix is not
an Amnesic Live CD.

40

00:02:16,008  -->  00:02:18,014
If you install Whonix
on your computer

41

00:02:18,094  -->  00:02:21,492
this will leave local traces
on the harddrive,

42

00:02:21,545  -->  00:02:24,261
that you installed Whonix
on that device.

43

00:02:24,562  -->  00:02:28,462
Any files you create will still
exist after powering off

44

00:02:28,548  -->  00:02:34,657
or rebooting unless you securely wiped
all signs of their previous existence.

45

00:02:34,730  -->  00:02:38,280
There are no special measures
to limit what is written to disk.

46

00:02:38,368  -->  00:02:42,437
This includes user created files,
backup files, temporary files,

47

00:02:42,527  -->  00:02:45,414
swap, chat history, browser
history and so on.

48

00:02:45,525  -->  00:02:49,030
Whonix acts like an ordinary
installed operating system."

49

00:02:49,138  -->  00:02:53,266
It also does not prevent the host
memory swaps to the host disk,

50

00:02:53,345  -->  00:02:57,858
as we discussed in the section
on VM weaknesses and data leaks.

51

00:02:58,512  -->  00:03:02,714
If you want an Amnesic system
or a system that forgets,

52

00:03:02,812  -->  00:03:06,813
much like Tails, there are a
couple of potential workarounds.

53

00:03:07,007  -->  00:03:08,936
You could use Snapshots

54

00:03:09,099  -->  00:03:14,369
and then restore back to a clean VM
after you’ve finished your activities,

55

00:03:14,635  -->  00:03:18,542
and another option is encrypting
the host operating system

56

00:03:18,642  -->  00:03:20,508
with full-disk encryption.

57

00:03:20,652  -->  00:03:24,158
These will help mitigate
local forensic examination,

58

00:03:24,283  -->  00:03:25,399
but they are not as good

59

00:03:25,459  -->  00:03:28,239
as not having the information
there in the first place.

60

00:03:28,787  -->  00:03:33,757
But Whonix isn’t designed to protect
against local forensic examination.

61

00:03:33,817  -->  00:03:37,279
That is not the threat model
that it is trying to mitigate.

62

00:03:37,461  -->  00:03:41,612
If this is your main concern,
then Whonix is not the best option.

63

00:03:41,990  -->  00:03:44,598
The threats that Whonix
is best suited to mitigate

64

00:03:44,768  -->  00:03:48,912
are protocol-level leaks
and ISP snooping.

65

00:03:49,056  -->  00:03:54,107
Whonix is not a one-click security,
privacy and anonymity solution.

66

00:03:54,263  -->  00:03:57,688
I recommend Whonix for
the more technical person

67

00:03:57,803  -->  00:03:59,973
or for anyone who’s willing
to spend some time

68

00:03:59,983  -->  00:04:01,923
really understanding
how it works.

69

00:04:02,070  -->  00:04:05,429
Then customize it
to your personal needs.

70

00:04:05,559  -->  00:04:09,764
The documentation is excellent and
goes into lots of detail about security,

71

00:04:09,824  -->  00:04:12,066
privacy and anonymity generally.

72

00:04:12,214  -->  00:04:15,284
So, a thank you to the Whonix
team for a great solution.

73

00:04:15,465  -->  00:04:18,091
Check it out if you haven’t
checked it out already.
